Skin Treatment Suitability Calculator
Assess Your Skin Treatment Needs
This tool helps determine which treatment might be most appropriate for your skin condition based on key factors. Remember: always consult your dermatologist before changing treatments.
Treatment Recommendations
Recommended Treatment Options
This recommendation is based on your responses. Always consult your dermatologist before changing treatments.
Tenovate is a potent topical steroid used to treat severe skin conditions like eczema, psoriasis, and dermatitis. Its active ingredient, clobetasol propionate, works fast to reduce redness, itching, and swelling. But it’s not the only option. Many people wonder if there are safer, cheaper, or equally effective alternatives - especially since long-term use of strong steroids like Tenovate can cause skin thinning, stretch marks, or even systemic side effects.
What Tenovate Actually Does
Tenovate contains clobetasol propionate at 0.05% concentration. That makes it a Class I steroid - the strongest available topically. It suppresses the immune response in the skin, which is why it works so well for flare-ups. In clinical trials, patients saw noticeable improvement in just 3-5 days. But here’s the catch: it’s meant for short-term use only. Doctors typically limit prescriptions to 2-4 weeks. Using it longer than that without supervision raises your risk of side effects.
It’s not for the face, groin, or underarms unless specifically directed. Even then, it’s usually prescribed in lower-strength versions or for just a few days. Many people don’t realize how powerful this cream is. It’s not a daily moisturizer. It’s a medical tool - like using a sledgehammer when you need a hammer.
Why People Look for Alternatives
There are three main reasons people search for alternatives to Tenovate:
- They’ve used it too long and developed skin thinning or rebound flare-ups
- They’re worried about side effects and want something gentler
- They can’t afford it - Tenovate isn’t always covered by insurance, and brand-name versions can cost over $60 for a 60g tube
Some switch to over-the-counter hydrocortisone creams. Others try natural oils or herbal remedies. But not all alternatives are equal. Some work well for mild cases. Others are outright dangerous if misused.
Top Alternatives to Tenovate
Here are the most common and clinically supported alternatives, ranked by strength and use case.
1. Betamethasone Valerate (0.1%)
This is probably the closest direct alternative. It’s also a Class I steroid, just like clobetasol. Studies show it has similar effectiveness for psoriasis and eczema. The main difference? Betamethasone valerate is often available as a foam or lotion - easier to apply on the scalp or hairy areas. Brands include Betnovate and Valisone. It’s slightly less likely to cause skin thinning than clobetasol, but still requires the same caution: short-term use only.
2. Mometasone Furoate (0.1%)
Class II steroid - strong, but a step below Tenovate. It’s often recommended for sensitive areas like the face or eyelids. A 2023 study in the Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology found it just as effective as clobetasol for mild-to-moderate atopic dermatitis, with fewer reports of skin atrophy. It’s also longer-lasting - one application can work for 24 hours. Brands include Elocon. If you need something strong but safer for daily use over a few weeks, this is a solid pick.
3. Hydrocortisone 2.5% (OTC)
This is the go-to for mild flare-ups. It’s a Class VII steroid - the weakest. It won’t touch a severe psoriasis plaque. But for small patches of red, itchy skin from contact dermatitis or insect bites? It works fine. You can buy it without a prescription. The downside? You’ll need to apply it 2-3 times a day. And if you’ve been using Tenovate for months, switching to this might feel like going from a jet engine to a bicycle. Don’t expect miracles. But for maintenance or mild cases? Perfect.
4. Pimecrolimus (1%) and Tacrolimus (0.03% or 0.1%)
These aren’t steroids at all. They’re calcineurin inhibitors - a different class of drugs that calm the immune system without thinning the skin. They’re FDA-approved for atopic dermatitis in adults and children over age 2. Elidel (pimecrolimus) and Protopic (tacrolimus) are the main brands. They don’t cause skin thinning, so they’re ideal for long-term use on the face or neck. The catch? They can cause a burning sensation when first applied. And they come with a black box warning about potential cancer risk - though no proven cases have been linked in over 20 years of use. Many dermatologists now consider them safer than long-term steroid use.
5. Crisaborole (2%)
This is a newer, non-steroidal option. It’s a PDE4 inhibitor that reduces inflammation. Approved for mild-to-moderate eczema in adults and kids over 3 months. It’s applied twice daily. No burning like calcineurin inhibitors. No skin thinning. No systemic absorption. It’s pricier than hydrocortisone but cheaper than Protopic. Brand name: Eucrisa. Good for people who want to avoid steroids entirely - especially parents of young children.
6. Natural and OTC Remedies (Coconut Oil, Aloe Vera, Oatmeal Baths)
These aren’t replacements for prescription steroids. But they can help manage symptoms. Coconut oil has been shown in small studies to improve skin barrier function in eczema. Colloidal oatmeal baths reduce itching. Aloe vera soothes redness. They work best alongside - not instead of - medical treatment. Don’t skip your doctor’s advice just because you’re trying a natural remedy. Some people delay proper care and end up with worse flare-ups.
Comparison Table: Tenovate vs Alternatives
| Product | Active Ingredient | Steroid Class | Best For | Side Effects | Cost (60g tube) | Prescription Needed? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tenovate | Clobetasol Propionate 0.05% | Class I (Strongest) | Severe psoriasis, thick eczema plaques | Skin thinning, stretch marks, rebound flare-ups | $55-$70 | Yes |
| Betnovate | Betamethasone Valerate 0.1% | Class I | Scalp, body plaques | Similar to Tenovate | $45-$65 | Yes |
| Elocon | Mometasone Furoate 0.1% | Class II | Face, sensitive skin, moderate eczema | Mild burning, rare thinning | $50-$70 | Yes |
| Elidel | Pimecrolimus 1% | Non-steroidal | Face, neck, long-term use | Burning on first use, rare cancer warning | $120-$180 | Yes |
| Protopic | Tacrolimus 0.03% or 0.1% | Non-steroidal | Chronic eczema, sensitive areas | Burning, stinging, rare cancer warning | $130-$200 | Yes |
| Eucrisa | Crisaborole 2% | Non-steroidal | Mild eczema in adults and children | Mild burning, no thinning | $100-$150 | Yes |
| Hydrocortisone 2.5% | Hydrocortisone 2.5% | Class VII (Weakest) | Mild itching, small patches | Minimal if used short-term | $8-$15 | No |
When to Switch from Tenovate
You should consider switching if:
- Your skin looks shiny, tight, or paper-thin
- You get redness or burning after stopping the cream
- You’ve used it for more than 4 weeks without improvement
- You’re applying it to your face, eyelids, or genitals
- You’re using it daily for months - even if you think it’s working
Don’t quit cold turkey. Stopping suddenly can cause a rebound flare - worse than before. Talk to your doctor about tapering off. They might switch you to a weaker steroid for a week, then move to a non-steroid like Eucrisa or Elidel.
What Not to Do
Don’t mix Tenovate with other steroids. Don’t use it on broken skin unless directed. Don’t cover it with plastic wrap unless your doctor says so - that increases absorption and risk. And don’t buy it online without a prescription. Counterfeit versions exist. Some contain hidden steroids or even mercury.
What Works Best Long-Term
The goal isn’t just to kill the flare-up. It’s to prevent the next one. That means:
- Moisturizing daily - even when skin looks fine
- Using fragrance-free, ceramide-based creams
- Avoiding hot showers and harsh soaps
- Identifying triggers: stress, dust mites, wool, sweat
- Keeping a symptom journal
Many people think steroids are the answer. But the real answer is skin barrier repair. That’s why dermatologists now recommend combining a short burst of strong steroid with daily moisturizing and non-steroid maintenance. It’s not about finding the strongest cream. It’s about building healthy skin.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Tenovate stronger than hydrocortisone?
Yes, Tenovate is about 500 times stronger than over-the-counter hydrocortisone 1%. Hydrocortisone is for minor irritation. Tenovate is for severe, stubborn skin conditions. They’re not interchangeable.
Can I use Tenovate on my face?
Only under strict medical supervision. The skin on your face is thinner and absorbs steroids more easily. Long-term use can cause acne, rosacea, or permanent redness. Mometasone or non-steroids like Elidel are safer for facial use.
Are non-steroid creams like Eucrisa and Elidel safe for kids?
Yes. Eucrisa is approved for children as young as 3 months. Elidel and Protopic are approved for kids over 2. They’re often preferred for children because they don’t cause skin thinning. Always follow dosing instructions - even non-steroids can irritate sensitive skin.
How long does it take for alternatives to work?
Steroids like Tenovate or Betnovate usually show results in 3-7 days. Non-steroids like Elidel or Eucrisa take longer - often 1-2 weeks to start working, and up to 4 weeks for full effect. Patience is key. They’re not fast fixes, but they’re safer for long-term use.
Can I use Tenovate and a moisturizer together?
Yes - and you should. Apply the steroid cream first, wait 15 minutes, then apply moisturizer. This helps the steroid absorb better and keeps your skin hydrated. Never mix them in the same jar. Always apply them separately.
Next Steps
If you’re currently using Tenovate and wondering if you should switch, start by tracking your symptoms for two weeks. Note where you apply it, how often, and what your skin looks like after. Then schedule a visit with your dermatologist or GP. Bring your current product and ask: “Is this still the best option for me?”
There’s no one-size-fits-all solution. What works for your neighbor might not work for you. The right choice depends on your skin type, condition severity, age, and medical history. Don’t guess. Get advice. Your skin will thank you.
